Shoulder replacement: anatomic or reverse, chosen for your shoulder
Shoulder replacement removes the worn joint surfaces and replaces them with smooth metal and plastic parts. It reliably relieves pain from advanced arthritis, cuff tear arthropathy and some fractures. The design is chosen by how well your rotator cuff works.
The two designs
Anatomic versus reverse
Radiographs of shoulder arthritis, anatomic replacement, and reverse replacement.
Before surgery, a CT scan is often used to plan implant size and position in 3D, especially when the socket is worn unevenly.
Understanding the operation
What is shoulder replacement?
Shoulder replacement treats a painful joint whose smooth cartilage surfaces have been destroyed by arthritis, a massive rotator cuff tear, a severe fracture or a previous operation that has failed. The damaged ball at the top of the arm bone is replaced with metal. When needed, the worn socket is resurfaced as well. The goal is to create a smooth, stable joint that reduces pain and allows the shoulder muscles to move the arm more effectively.
Replacement is not recommended from an X-ray alone. The decision is based on how much the shoulder hurts, how much it limits sleep and daily life, what the examination shows, whether nonsurgical care has been adequate, and whether the anatomy can be reconstructed reliably.
Who may benefit
Common reasons to consider replacement
Advanced arthritis with joint-space loss, stiffness and bone spurs
Pain at night or at rest and difficulty dressing, reaching or using the arm
Symptoms that remain unacceptable despite medication, injections, activity changes or therapy
Cuff tear arthropathy or a massive irreparable rotator cuff tear
Selected complex fractures, loss of blood supply to the humeral head or failed prior shoulder surgery
The decision is personal
Replacement may not be the first step
Mild symptoms that are still controlled with nonsurgical treatment
Pain coming primarily from the neck, nerves or another structure outside the joint
An active infection or a medical condition that makes elective surgery unsafe
Expectations that do not match what an artificial joint can safely provide
Age matters less than the combination of pain, function, health, anatomy and personal goals.
How Dr. Ramirez determines whether you are a candidate
1
Your symptoms and goals
We discuss pain, sleep, work, sports, prior treatment and the activities you want to regain. Replacement is considered when the burden of the shoulder is greater than the limitations and risks of surgery.
2
A focused examination
Motion, strength, stability, rotator cuff function, nerve function and the neck are checked to confirm that the arthritic joint is the main source of the problem.
3
X-rays and three-dimensional planning
X-rays show cartilage loss, bone spurs, deformity and the position of the humeral head. A CT scan is often used to measure socket wear and plan implant size, position and correction in three dimensions. MRI or ultrasound may be used when rotator cuff integrity is uncertain.
4
Choose the safest design
The final recommendation combines rotator cuff function, bone quality, socket shape, age, activity, prior surgery and the amount of correction required. Dr. Ramirez reviews the options and explains why an anatomic or reverse replacement best fits your shoulder.
Working rotator cuff
Anatomic total shoulder replacement
An anatomic replacement recreates the normal ball-and-socket relationship. A polished metal ball replaces the humeral head, and a smooth plastic component resurfaces the glenoid. The rotator cuff must be able to center and control the new ball. It is most often used for primary osteoarthritis with an intact cuff.
In a conventional operation, the subscapularis tendon is released for access and then repaired. Selected patients may qualify for the tendon-sparing technique described below.
Cuff deficiency or complex reconstruction
Reverse total shoulder replacement
A reverse replacement places a metal ball on the shoulder blade and a socket on the arm bone. Changing the center of rotation allows the deltoid to raise the arm when the rotator cuff cannot do its job.
It is commonly chosen for cuff tear arthropathy, massive irreparable tears, selected fractures, severe bone loss and many revision operations. It is not simply a “better” implant; it solves a different mechanical problem.
What happens during surgery?
1 · AnesthesiaNerve block and general anesthesiaThe block helps control pain during the first postoperative hours.
2 · ReconstructionDamaged surfaces are removedThe bone is prepared and the planned metal and plastic components are implanted.
3 · Final checksBalance, stability and motionDr. Ramirez confirms implant position, joint stability, soft-tissue tension and safe range of motion.
4 · RecoverySling, exercises and follow-upMany patients go home the same day or after one night. Rehabilitation is matched to the procedure and tissues that need protection.
What replacement can—and cannot—do
The primary goal is reliable pain relief. Most patients also gain motion, strength, sleep and independence over the following months. A replacement does not make the shoulder biologically normal, and repetitive heavy loading can shorten implant life. Dr. Ramirez will help set activity goals that protect the reconstruction while returning you to the life you want to lead.
Patient example
Three months after reverse shoulder arthroplasty
This patient had severe shoulder osteoarthritis combined with a rotator cuff tear. Because the damaged cuff could no longer reliably center and power the arthritic joint, a reverse shoulder replacement was used so the deltoid muscle could help restore shoulder elevation.
Postoperative X-ray showing the reverse shoulder replacement.At three months, the patient demonstrates functional overhead motion after reverse shoulder arthroplasty. Individual recovery and results vary.
New technology
Subscapularis-sparing total shoulder replacement
Dr. Miguel Ramirez is the only surgeon in Central Illinois performing subscapularis-sparing total shoulder arthroplasty.
Most anatomic shoulder replacements require the subscapularis—the large rotator cuff tendon across the front of the shoulder—to be detached and repaired so the surgeon can reach the joint. With a subscapularis-sparing technique, Dr. Ramirez reaches the arthritic joint while keeping this tendon attached.
Because there is no subscapularis repair to protect, carefully selected patients may begin active motion and everyday use sooner and may have fewer tendon-healing restrictions during early recovery. This can mean a quicker return to light daily activities. Lifting, driving, work and sports still advance according to each patient's implant fixation, bone quality and individualized recovery plan.
Could you be a candidate?
This approach is designed for selected patients whose anatomy, rotator cuff and bone quality permit it. Talk with Dr. Ramirez about whether it fits your shoulder and your goals; he will review your examination and imaging before recommending the safest approach.
Two-week recovery example after subscapularis-sparing total shoulder arthroplasty. Individual recovery varies.
Preparing
Your preparation checklist
Tick items off as you go. These come from Dr. Ramirez's preoperative instructions.
2 to 3 weeks before
7 days before
At home
Day of surgery
This checklist is for your own use on this page and is not saved or sent anywhere.
Surgery day
What to expect on the day
1
Nerve block
An anesthesiologist numbs your arm with a nerve block that lasts about 12 to 36 hours, plus general anesthesia.
2
The operation
Usually 1 to 2 hours through an incision at the front of the shoulder.
3
Recovery room
You wake up in a sling. The arm may feel numb and heavy; that is the block working.
4
Going home
Healthy patients with help at home can go home the same day; most others stay one night. Start pain medicine before the block wears off.
Recovery
Drag through your recovery
013263952
Typical anatomic timeline. After a reverse, the sling usually comes off at about 2 weeks; the other limits are similar.
Safe pain control
We use scheduled acetaminophen, ice and, when allowed, anti-inflammatory medicine as the foundation. Opioids are for breakthrough pain only, at the lowest dose for the shortest time; misuse is less likely when they are taken 5 days or less. For major procedures we prescribe no more than 40 pills and aim to stop opioids within 2 weeks. Never combine them with sleep aids or anxiety medicines, and dispose of leftovers at a pharmacy or police drop box.
Call the office if you have
Fever over 101°F, increasing redness, warmth or drainage, pain not controlled by your medicine, numbness that persists after the nerve block has worn off (beyond 24 to 48 hours), or marked swelling of the hand. For chest pain or trouble breathing, call 911. After hours, call (309) 676-5546 and ask for the orthopaedic surgeon on call.
Results and risks
What results to expect
Most patientsreport major pain relief and better sleep
~90%+of implants still working at 10 years in large registries
Dr. Ramirez serves as Chief Medical Officer of Catalyst OrthoScience, a shoulder replacement company. The implant used is chosen for your anatomy and needs. Please ask about this relationship at any time.
Check your understanding
Three quick questions
For the first 6 weeks, which of these should you avoid?
Pushing up stresses the repaired front tendon and the new joint. Elbow motion and waist-level tasks are encouraged.
When can you usually take the bandage off?
Leave it on through day 4 and remove it on day 5.
When can you drive?
Most people meet these conditions around 2 to 3 weeks.
Pick an answer to check yourself.
Common questions
Questions patients ask
Will I need formal physical therapy?
Many patients can do therapy at home. Patients without a well-working other shoulder, or who cannot do their own exercises, are referred to outpatient therapy.
When is my first visit?
About 10 to 14 days after surgery. Ask about virtual post-op visits.
How long will I be in the hospital?
Often same day or one night. Patients who need a skilled nursing facility may stay up to 3 nights.
Can I sleep on that side?
Not at first. Most people sleep propped up for 2 to 4 weeks and gradually return to side sleeping by about 6 to 12 weeks.
Talk with us about shoulder replacement
Bring your X-rays. We will review whether your rotator cuff supports an anatomic or reverse replacement and what recovery will look like for you.
(309) 676-5546
Great Plains Orthopaedics · Peoria, Illinois · Se habla español
Disclosure: Dr. Ramirez is Chief Medical Officer of Catalyst OrthoScience, a shoulder arthroplasty company.
This page provides general education and does not replace an examination or individualized medical advice. Last reviewed October 2026. For emergencies, call 911.