Shoulder and elbow fractures: what heals in a sling, what needs repair
Falls, sports and car accidents can break the collarbone, the top of the arm bone, the shoulder blade or the bones around the elbow. Many fractures heal well in a sling. Others heal better, or only, with surgery. The difference depends on how far the pieces moved, which bone broke, and your age and activity.
Anatomy
Tap a bone to learn about its fractures
Simplified front view of the right shoulder and elbow.
Evidence
Sling or surgery: what trials show
Proximal humerus · 250 patients
Surgery was not better for most displaced fractures
In the UK PROFHER trial (average age 66), patients treated in a sling had the same shoulder function at 2 years as those who had surgery. Surgery is reserved for specific patterns and active patients.
Collarbone · 132 patients
Plates helped active adults with fully displaced fractures
In a Canadian randomized trial, plating gave better function, faster healing (16 vs 28 weeks) and fewer nonunions than a sling. The most common reason for another surgery was plate removal.
Collarbone fractures that failed to heal or healed badly displaced (one year)
Sling
16 of 49
Plate
2 of 62
Canadian Orthopaedic Trauma Society, J Bone Joint Surg Am 2007. Nonunion plus symptomatic malunion.
Find your path
Which injury sounds like yours?
Healing
How fractures heal
Weeks 0–2InflammationSwelling and bruising, which can track down the arm. Pain control, ice, keep fingers moving.
Weeks 2–6Soft callusNew bone bridges the gap. Gentle motion as directed; no lifting.
Weeks 6–12Hard callusThe fracture becomes solid on X-ray. Strengthening begins.
Months 3–12RemodelingBone reshapes and regains full strength. Return to heavy work and sport.
Things that slow bone healing
Smoking and nicotine, diabetes, low vitamin D, some medicines and poor nutrition. Stopping nicotine is the single most helpful step you can take.
Get help now
Go to the emergency room if
Bone has broken through the skin, or there is a wound over the fracture
Your hand is numb, cold, pale or blue
Pain keeps rising despite medicine and elevation, especially with tight swelling in the forearm
You also hit your head, have trouble breathing or have chest pain
Check your understanding
Three quick questions
Do most fractures of the top of the arm bone need surgery?
About 4 in 5 heal in a sling, and a large trial showed no advantage to surgery for many displaced fractures.
Why do we start elbow motion early?
The elbow stiffens quickly, and stiffness is the most common long-term problem after elbow injuries.
Which sign means go to the emergency room?
A cold or numb hand can mean an artery or nerve is injured. Bruising tracking down the arm is common and expected.
Pick an answer to check yourself.
Talk with us about your injury
Bring your X-rays or emergency room report. We will review the fracture pattern and your goals, and explain whether a sling or surgery gives you the better result.
(309) 676-5546
Great Plains Orthopaedics · Peoria, Illinois · Se habla español
Rangan A, et al. Surgical vs nonsurgical treatment of adults with displaced fractures of the proximal humerus: the PROFHER randomized clinical trial. JAMA. 2015;313(10):1037–1047. doi:10.1001/jama.2015.1629
Canadian Orthopaedic Trauma Society. Nonoperative treatment compared with plate fixation of displaced midshaft clavicular fractures. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(1):1–10. doi:10.2106/JBJS.F.00020
This page provides general education and does not replace an examination or individualized medical advice. Last reviewed October 2026. For emergencies, call 911.